Rick Perry And Texas Job Numbers

Full disclosure: I don’t like Rick Perry for our next president. I have my reasons that aren’t worth going into here. However, when I was watching the GOP debate and pro-Perry people started bringing up Rick Perry’s job numbers as a cudgel against other candidates, I looked into the BLS data on Texas jobs. Having familiarized myself with the data, I started noticing claims on the Texas jobs data that started popping up that directly contradicted what I was seeing in the data. So I wanted to clear up a couple of these common misconceptions.

Note: If you are going to comment and you want to introduce some new objection to the Texas job numbers, you MUST provide original data. I spent about 4 hours digging through raw data to write this post. I don’t want you to point to some pundit or blog post and take it on their authority, because I’ve already researched several idiot pundits who are talking directly out of their asses when it comes to the data. I want you to point to the raw data that I can examine for myself. This means links. I refuse to waste any more of my time on speculative bullshit or “Well, I’ll wager that the Texas jobs don’t really count because…” If you’re willing to wager, take that money and put it towards finding the actual data. In short, put up or shut up.

I’m not cranky, I swear.

Anyway, let’s deal with the complaints in no particular order:

“Texas has an unemployment rate of 8.2%. That’s hardly exceptional.”

See… that’s what I thought when I started looking at the data. I knew that Utah had a lower unemployment rate than Texas and I kept hearing that Texas was go great at jobs, blah, blah, blah, so I looked up the unemployment rate.

Nothing special.

So I was going to drive my point home that Texas was nothing special by looking at their raw employment numbers and reporting on those. That’s when I saw this:

This may not look like anything special, but I’ve been looking closely at employment data for a couple years now and I’ve become very accustomed to seeing data that looks like this.

In a “normal” employment data set, we can easily look at it and say “Yep, that’s where the recession happened. Sucks to be us.” But not with Texas. With Texas, we say “Damn. Looks like they’ve recovered already.”

(To get to this data, go to this link http://data.bls.gov/cgi-bin/dsrv?la then select the state or states you want, the select “Statewide”, then select the states again, then select the metrics you want to see.)

But if Texas has so many jobs, why do they have such a high unemployment rate? Let’s take a closer look at that data.

As a percentage of the number of pre-recession jobs, here is a chart of the growth of a selection of states. (For clarity, in this chart I selected a number of the largest states and tried to focus on states that have relatively good economic reputations. I did not chart all 50 states b/c it would have taken me too long.)

We can see that Texas has grown the fastest, having increased jobs by 2.2% since the recession started. I want to take a moment and point out that second place is held by North Dakota. I added North Dakota to my list of states  to show something very important. North Dakota currently has the lowest unemployment rate of any state at 3.2%. And yet Texas is adding jobs at a faster rate than North Dakota. How can this be?

The reason is that people are flocking to Texas in massive numbers. Starting at the beginning of the recession (December 2007), let’s look at how this set of states have grown in their labor force.

As you can see, Texas isn’t just the fastest growing… it’s growing over twice as fast as the second fastest state and three times as fast as the third. Given that Texas is (to borrow a technical term) f***ing huge, this growth is incredible.

People are flocking to Texas in massive numbers. This is speculative, but it *seems* that people are moving to Texas looking for jobs rather than moving to Texas for a job they already have lined up. This would explain why Texas is adding jobs faster than any other state but still has a relatively high unemployment rate.

“Sure, Texas has lots of jobs, but they’re mostly low-paying/minimum wage jobs”

Let’s look at the data. Here’s a link: Occupational Employment and Wage Estimates

Texas median hourly wage is $15.14…  almost exactly in the middle of the pack (28th out of 51 regions). Given that they’ve seen exceptional job growth (and these other states have not) this does not seem exceptionally low.

But the implication here is that the new jobs in Texas, the jobs that Texas seems to stand alone in creating at such a remarkable pace, are low paying jobs and don’t really count.

If this were true, all these new low-paying jobs should be dragging down the wages data, right? But if we look at the wages data since the beginning of the recession (click to enlarge, states are listed alphabetically)

And it turns out that the opposite is true. Since the recession started hourly wages in Texas have increased at a 6th fastest pace in the nation.

As a side note, the only blue state that has faster growing wages is Hawaii. Just thought I’d get that jab in since so many people have been making snarky “Yeah, I could get a job in Texas is I wanted to flip burgers!” comments at me on Twitter.

“Texas is oil country and the recent energy boom is responsible for the incredible jobs increase.”

In identifying “energy jobs” I cast as wide a net as possible. If you want to replicate my findings, go to this link: http://www.bls.gov/sae/data.htm, click on “One-Screen Data Search”, then select “Texas”, then select “Statewide”, then in Supersectors select “Mining and Logging”, “Non-Durable Goods” and “Transportation and Utilities” and then in Industries select “Mining and Logging”, “Natural Gas Distribution”, “Electric Power Generation” and “Petroleum and Coal Products Manufacturing”.

Tedious, I know, but transparency is important and this is how you get the data.

When we finally get the data, we discover that energy isn’t really the biggest part of the Texas economy. Increases in jobs in the energy sector (or closely related to it) account for about 25% of the job increases in the last year. Since the energy sector only makes up 3% of all employment, there is some truth to this claim.

However, take the energy sector completely out of the equation and Texas is still growing faster than any other state. This indicates to us that the energy sector is not a single sector saving Texas from the same economic fate as the rest of the states. It’s not hurting, but Texas would still be growing like a weed without it.

“Texas has 100,000 unsustainable public sector jobs that inflate the growth numbers.”

I’m not sure where this one comes from, but the numbers are these (and can be found by selecting government employment from the data wizard at this link http://www.bls.gov/sae/data.htm):

Counting from the beginning of the recession (December 2007) the Texas public sector has grown 3.8%, or a little under 70,000 employees. This is faster than normal employment, but it’s not off the charts.

Given that the Texas economy has grown so much and private sector jobs have grown so much, that doesn’t strike me as an unsustainable growth in the public sector.

But, just in case you’re really worried about it, you can lay your fears to rest because in the last year the Texas public sector has shrunk by 26,000 jobs. In the last 12 months, Texas lost 31,300 federal employees, trimmed 3,800 state jobs, and increased local government jobs by 8,400 jobs.

(To be fair, this was partially driven by the role Texas employees played in the census, which inflated federal job numbers this time last year. Since the census numbers stabilized, federal employment has been at about break-even.)

As you can see, we’re nowhere near the “100,000 unsustainable jobs” number.

My Personal Favorite Chart

I’ll leave you with my personal favorite chart. I mentioned at the beginning that Texas is seeing high unemployment in a large part because they’re growing so damn fast. The problem with this from a charts and graphs perspective is that it leaves worse states off the hook, making them look better than they actually are. Looking at unemployment alone, we would conclude that Wisconsin has a better economy than Texas. But Wisconsin is still 120K short of it’s pre-recession numbers. The only reason they look better than Texas is because 32,000 people fled the state.

During that time, 739,000 people fled into Texas. Anyone who takes that data and pretends that this is somehow bad news for Texas is simply not being honest. At the worst, I’d call it a good problem to have.

So, to give something of a better feeling for the economic situation across states, this chart takes the population of the states I selected above and judges the current job situation against the population as it stood at the beginning of the recession.

Using that metric, Texas would have a very low unemployment rate of 2.3%. But the fact that unemployment in the United States is fluid means that the unemployed flock to a place where there are jobs, which inflates its unemployment rate (at least in the short term). It’s not a bad thing for Texas… it just looks bad when dealing with the isolated “unemployment %” statistic.

UPDATE: @francisgagnon on Twitter felt that this chart was dishonest because it charts Texas as having 2.3% unemployment and (in his words so I don’t get him wrong): “It assumes immigrants create no jobs. But more people = more consumers = more jobs.”

He is absolutely right about this. I tried to be clear above that this chart doesn’t account for the fluid nature of an economy with immigration and departures of hundreds of thousands of people, but I don’t want to leave anyone with the wrong impression. So here it is: This chart doesn’t account for the fluid nature of an economy with immigrations and departures of hundreds of thousands of people. The point of this chart is not to say “Texas should have 2.3% unemployment if only things were fair.” Instead, it is an attempt to chart job growth in such a way that controls for people leaving one job market to enter another. To say “Wisconsin has a better job market than Texas because its unemployment rate is 0.6% lower” is a wholly untrue statement even though it cites accurate numbers. What this chart is meant to do is not posit a counter-factual, but to give a visual representation of the employment reality that is obscured by the way we calculate unemployment numbers.

END UPDATE

And… that’s it.

You may have noticed that I don’t mention Rick Perry very much here. That is because Rick Perry is, in my opinion, ancillary to this entire discussion. He was governor while these these numbers happened, so good for him. Maybe that means these jobs they are his “fault”. Maybe the job situation is the result of his policies. Or maybe Texas is simply the least bad option in a search for a favorable economic climate.

That is not an argument I’m having at this exact moment. My point is to show that most of the “excuses” you will hear about Texas’ job statistics are based in nothing more than a hope that Rick Perry had nothing to do with them and not on a sound understanding of the data.

My advice to anti-Perry advocates is this: Give up talking about Texas jobs. Texas is an incredible outlier among the states when it comes to jobs. Not only are they creating them, they’re creating ones with higher wages.

One can argue that Perry had very little to do with the job situation in Texas, but such a person should be probably prepare themselves for the consequences of that line of reasoning. If Rick Perry had nothing to do with creating jobs in Texas, than why does Obama have something to do with creating jobs anywhere? And why would someone advocate any sort of “job creating” policies if policies don’t seem to matter when it comes to the decade long governor of Texas? In short, it seems to me that this line of reasoning, in addition to sounding desperate and partisan, hogties its adherents into a position where they are simultaneously saying that government doesn’t create jobs while arguing for a set of policies where government will create jobs.

Or, to an uncharitable eye, it seem they are saying “Policies create jobs when they are policies I like. They don’t create jobs when they are policies I dislike.”

People will continue to argue about the data. But hopefully this will be helpful in sorting out reality from wishful and desperate thinking. I mentioned on Twitter that the Texas jobs situation was nothing short of miraculous. This is why I said that and why I’m standing by that statement.

650 comments

  1. Tom says:

    The Bureau of Labor Statisitcs has a great wealth of data. I am glad that someone took this data and turned it into useful information. You may agree or disagree with this data (I tend to agree with the conclusions made here). I really enjoy seeing someone taking the time to review the situation and come up with some truly independent conclusions. It is a shame that the Boston Globe, NY Times, etc.. could not be expected to do the same.

  2. Fellas
    If you are looking for a portable and affordable vaporizer you guys should try Sneak A Vape vaporizer. For 39 bucks you get this discrete vaporizer and a portable pollen press as a gift. The only thing is that this vape can also burn the weed if the flame is not properly adjust.

  3. Michael Hitchcock says:

    I think you underestimate the role of energy production in the Texas miracle. Texas (unlike California, where I live) has an oil and gas severance tax of 4.6% of market value for oil and 7.5% for gas (http://www.rrc.state.tx.us/programs/og/severancetax.php). Since Texas is a big oil producer, that’s a lot of money that stays in the state instead of going wherever the oil companies want to take it. That money is then spent by the state government for wages and purchases of goods and services. I can’t calculate the multiplier effect of the expenditures, but it does give Texas an advantage over most other states.

  4. […] for a long time. Whether it’s all his doing or not, Texas’ job stats right now are even better than they look on first glance. Seems like a nice, exciting conservative. Cons: Mandated an HPV vaccine for […]

  5. Adam Bash says:

    great blog…will definitely be back to check out your newer stuff again…OR I can just subscribe…im such a dumb a.. sometimes lol

  6. mr kessler says:

    i fucking hate this class and i really would like it if you died and lost your fake teeth love tim

  7. […] Perry seemed to have two clear advantages over the rest of the field: his genuinely strong jobs record in Texas, and his engaged and confrontational style, which seemed to suit the Republican mood and […]

  8. jim says:

    Would love to know the relationship between the jobs and housing in texas. TX was one of the few places in the country that did not have a speculative housing market in the first half of the 00s, and thus, I’d anticipate that the recession hangover in that industry was not as bad there as elsewhere. Add to that the rapid population growth and I would guess (only that) that the housing industry has continued to be pretty healthy there. Since there is no manufacturing left in America, housing has an outsized impact on job growth.

  9. […] Perry seemed to have two clear advantages over the rest of the field: his genuinely strong jobs record in Texas, and his engaged and confrontational style, which seemed to suit the Republican mood and […]

  10. […] and economic prosperity. Those two things go together and Rick Perry understands that. He is America’s Jobs Governor and that is beyond […]

  11. […] and economic prosperity. Those two things go together and Rick Perry understands that. He is America’s Jobs Governor and that is beyond […]

  12. […] More on the Texas job success story here. […]

  13. […] one-term governor of a medium-sized state — and his signature accomplishment in office was a strong job-creation record rather than shepherding the passage of a health care bill that is substantively similar to […]

  14. […] one-term governor of a medium-sized state — and his signature accomplishment in office was a strong job-creation record rather than shepherding the passage of a health care bill that is substantively similar to […]

  15. susan says:

    good article!

  16. […] one-term governor of a medium-sized state — and his signature accomplishment in office was a strong job-creation record rather than shepherding the passage of a health care bill that is substantively similar to […]

  17. […] one-term administrator of a medium-sized state — and his signature fulfilment in bureau was a strong job-creation record rather than shepherding a thoroughfare of a health caring check that is substantively identical to […]

  18. Delmer Drees says:

    For several people, the weekly paycheck is ‘take-home pay’ because residence is the sole place they could afford to choose it.
    A cardinal principle of Total Quality escapes too many managers: you can’t continuously improve interdependent systems and operations before you progressively perfect interdependent, interpersonal relationships.

  19. Ashley says:

    Can you please name your charts, im having hard time with this

  20. Shawn T says:

    This is great stuff man. I love the way people try to poke holes in your argument by demanding PROOF. All of these statistics are easily found in FEDERAL Databases. Too many people just want to write off Texas as being racist, uneducated etc etc. So they hate the fact that places like Texas are seen as being smarter than their centrally planned states when real numbers and facts are used. Way to put in some incredible research you rock man

  21. […] The biggest threat to Obama comes from the success Texas has enjoyed economically.  Texas’ success is a direct result of our system of government and limited intervention.  Unlike California, our economic success has been a result of that limited intervention.  A detailed analysis of our economic success in Texas is illustrated here. […]

  22. По последним исследованиям ученых-социологов, 10% из 100% исследованых людей предпочитают смотреть в интернете [url=http://pornofabrika.ru/?cat=313]порно со зрелыми мамами [/url], а я не думаю что именно 10% людей занимаются просмотром видео такой тематики.

  23. Can I print one of your charts ?

  24. SteveDeverux says:

    Cheers for this advice $author, I’ll be sure to bookmark this page and re-read some of this content again. – Steve

  25. […] 2012 Employment Statistics – Texas Workforce CommissionTexas Ahead: Tracking the Texas EconomyRick Perry And Texas Job Numbers « Political Mathstatistician jobs in Texas | careerjet.comMathematics Statistics Jobs, Employment in Texas | […]

  26. click here says:

    I have got one idea for your weblog. It looks like right now there are a handful of cascading stylesheet problems when launching a selection of web pages inside google chrome and firefox. It is operating alright in internet explorer. Perhaps you can double check this.

  27. click here says:

    If you dont mind, where do you host your site? I am searching for a great host and your website appears to be extremely fast and up all the time

  28. […] may have posted this before, but it bears repeating: the “Texas only creates low-paying jobs” myth debunked. “It turns out that the opposite is true. Since the recession started hourly wages in Texas […]

  29. I’m just writing to make you understand of the great encounter my child had reading through yuor web blog. She came to understand too many details, which included how it is like to have an ideal giving mood to have a number of people with ease fully understand various advanced things. You truly exceeded our own expectations. Thanks for presenting the informative, healthy, edifying and easy guidance on that topic to Tanya.

  30. drawlwoli says:

    В марте 2012 года, американские ученные провели ислледования с целью узнать как влияет [url=http://pornocentr.ru/]бесплатное 3d порно онлайн смотреть [/url], и выяснили что просмотр видео позволяет разнообразить сексуальную жизнь и и начать жить полной жизнью.

  31. Aimara says:

    great work by posting this…thanks.http://www.bobinasplasticas.net

  32. Erlese says:

    can you explain more about your post? actually, i cannot understand it fully.http://www.detetizar.com

  33. seo services says:

    Thats some intresting informationI would like to read more about it. computer repair computer repair computer repair computer repair repair pc web seo services

  34. rikervrikery says:

    When you actually light something to the first test: the oven, the fireplace, a candlepower unit, a cigarette. I don’t have any make on my attention. All I’ve on is my absolute elf blemish powder. I’m thinking about purchasing the elf acne spot zapper up coming! There was a correspondence of explanation within the sewer bill. The village has used a brand new calculation to ascertain usage and count on Aquarion for statistics. I am undecided what all the stink is concerning because this bills are based on actual usage versus past when they were definitely not. And, of study course, they are definitely more in price tag. Perhaps it’ll be a wakeup get in touch with to individuals that use by far the most scared commodity on the earth: water. Although I actually doubt the item. Dependence with oil, and it’s related pitfalls, certainly have not curtailed each of our driving massive SUV’s. So spoiled and most people don’t sometimes know it. Sad
    [url=http://www.antiagecreamreviews.com/hydroxatone-review/]hydroxatone cream[/url]
    buy hydroxatone
    http://www.antiagecreamreviews.com/hydroxatone-review/
    Taking an opportunity on any REALY extensive driving holiday with all of your siblings within the cramped car. That feeling when you initially stand upwards and heard the gratifying POP within your knees. Letting farts rip in class and once someone learns playing along and showing them it turned out the person adjacent to you. Licking the fingers immediately after eating a thing extrordinarily sticky including watermelon as well as icecream. When any cat will certainly play fetch to you! Larry 2-3 weeks back on the corporate call up, One24 said that they will start expanding internationally inside 4th one fourth of 2011

  35. 420 college says:

    420 College is the premier medical marijuana school in California. We’ve been helping people find a new career in America’s most exciting new medical marijuana industry since March of 2009

  36. http://www.jerseysqueens.co.uk/ soccer jerseys,Soccer Shirt,Wholesale Socer Jerseys,Football Jerseys,cheap soccer jerseys,soccer jerseys cheap,authentic soccer jerseys,cheap soccer shirts,wholesale soccer shirts
    http://www.jerseys-queens.com/ youth soccer jerseys|soccer jerseys|cheap soccer jerseys|soccer jerseys cheap|authentic soccer jerseys|cheap soccer shirts|wholesale soccer shirts|soccer Shirt|Football Jerseys|Wholesale Socer Jerseys

  37. Thanks for the guidelines you have provided here. Another thing I would like to talk about is that personal computer memory specifications generally increase along with other advancements in the engineering. For instance, any time new generations of cpus are made in the market, there is usually a similar increase in the size and style preferences of all computer memory along with hard drive space. This is because the application operated by means of these processors will inevitably rise in power to use the new technological innovation.

  38. Do you ever present any chances for the viewers to contribute? I would like to produce something for your web page to help out!

  39. Alcione says:

    i really enjoyed reading this. thanks for the post.http://www.divulgaemail.com

  40. Belmira says:

    nice information, thanks for your blog.http://www.listasegmentada.com

  41. Teresa Mayes sagte den Ermittlern, dass bei sie sah, Ihre Liebsten Ehemann zu töten jede und jeder über Das gesamte Garage alle jene Bain bestimmten Haus in der Nähe Whiteville, Tennessee, und neben der Dann fuhr sie ihn, dieses jüngeren Mädchen zusätzlich die du kannst , aus Gericht sagen. [url=http://www.schmuckarmband.com]pandora ohrringe[/url]
    Dienstag der Abstimmung während auf der Darlehen Rechnung, die weitgehend auf Partisan Linien, kam a great Morgen eine Person sehr ein brandneues Ein-Jahres- Erweiterung des Zugehörigkeit zur 3,4 Prozent Zins auf Bundes-Studenten Darlehen. Brown sagte, es ist Gelegenheit mit Begleitung Die Besten parteiübergreifende Lösung [url=http://www.schmuckarmband.com]pandora armband[/url]
    Das wichtigste Senatsabstimmung vor kurzem war wirklich weitgehend symbolisch, weil die Demokratischen Gesetzentwurf keine Chance für von Ihrem GOP-geführten Haus. Dienstag der Abstimmung früher im Rahmen der wie auf zwischen beginnend Debatte mit verknüpften in Richtung der demokratischen Gesetzgebung – – acht Stimmen schüchtern derer hinsichtlich Art der Rechnung nach vorn.
    http://www.schmuckarmband.com

  42. Bernadete says:

    my friend, i am now a big fan of yours and your blog’s follower, thanks for the help.http://www.divulgaemail.com

  43. Daisy says:

    fantastic blog for read, i hope all reader will enjoy…keep up the share.http://www.divulgaemail.com

  44. JAILAMYMN says:

    Right now We’ve E. L. F. cosmetics on my eyes at this time! Thanks for accomplishing this contest!! I like especially this pattern way, didn’t believe that way.. huh..:) Hi anyone, I’ve your niggle… Yahoo roadmaps keeps beginning up on it is rather own around background as well as taking tons of battery by using it. For model, yesterday When i took that off charge but it was sat idle considering the screen blanked for about 4 hours. When My spouse and i flicked this on I actually was amazed to discover that your battery ended up being only 50% full that is negative even to your x10! When I checked what seemed to be working, I located Moxier mailbox (not any surprises right now there) plus Yahoo Maps.
    [url=http://freeconsumerreviews.org/zquiet-couch/]zquiet testimonials[/url]
    buy zquiet
    I can’t see through step 3c everything i actually do to as it happens wrong and yes it just keeps turning it into look like you’ll find lines on the blocks every suggestions about how to repair it. Hey, I was not quarrelling our reputation there. Matter regarding fact, I think historians look at “W” as well as applaud his / her entrance within Iraq. My unique supposition was a reply to your question: why may be the War in Terror an inability? And this answer (however lengthly, sorry) treated such. I imagine Afganistan is actually a winless endless war although the CIA drone strikes (got up through Obama) are already successful. I think 3 trillion cash and 100, 000 everyday life was in order to costly a cost on Iraq in particular considering just what our economic climate is currently. But I are in agreement with you: a presence is needed. Yet, in this time of technological warfare and hi-tech intelligence, do we really need ground soldiers? My thinking is the fact that War in Terror is a failure, not because the device wasn’t needed but also in the avenues the goverment/military currently have utilized. And I do not think the litmus test of “we did not been bombarded in 9 years” is surely an accurate barometer than it success. The moment in time of happiness once you listen with a song you haven’t heard in the while and also you remember all of the lyrics. The radio’s upon, and you happen to be absently paying attention to some melodies and generating with a number of friends. You pick up a familiar chord along with suddenly your foot’s a-tappin’ whilst your head’s a-bobbin’. It’s an example of your songs that a person haven’t heard in age range. The first verse is usually a little rugged, but from then on catchy chorus, floods with rhymes and melodies flow off you happen to be tongue. You had the ability to recollect nearly all word. This song need to be that good in which to stay your head for so very long. Just like locating a lost earring in the sock compartment, you could actually wade through any devices in your cluttered thoughts and extract an enjoyable, valuable section of information. AWESOME!
    http://freeconsumerreviews.org/zquiet-couch/

  45. Farah says:

    writing is not a easy thing to do, it takes creativity and good sense, and you’ve got it!http://www.paletesplasticos.com